Introduction
In 2019, director Phillip Noyce brought to the screen the tragic and gripping story of Susan Smith, the first woman ever to bring down an FBI agent. Based on real-life events, Above Suspicion delivers an unflinching look at power, manipulation, and the human cost of obsession. The film is set in the remote town of Pikeville, Kentucky, a place where desperation and secrets collide. With its bleak atmosphere and disturbing narrative, this film leaves a lasting impression.
The Plot: A Dangerous Obsession
Above Suspicion begins in the impoverished Appalachian town of Pikeville, Kentucky. Here, we meet Susan Smith (Emilia Clarke), a troubled woman struggling with addiction, poverty, and a feeling of being trapped in a life that seems to have no way out. Enter FBI agent Mark Putnam (Jack Huston), who is assigned to investigate the area. His arrival quickly turns Susan’s life upside down as he recruits her as an informant.
What begins as a professional relationship quickly spirals into something much darker. Their connection deepens, becoming dangerously personal and obsessive. As the story unfolds, we witness the blurring of lines between authority and manipulation, as well as the tragic consequences of exploitation. The film builds toward a shocking crime that exposes the very core of human frailty and desperation.
Performances: Emilia Clarke’s Standout Role
Emilia Clarke delivers a powerful and layered performance as Susan Smith. Known for her role in Game of Thrones, Clarke dives deep into the character of Susan, capturing her vulnerability, desperation, and simmering charm. Clarke’s portrayal allows the audience to feel the emotional weight of Susan’s decisions, drawing us into her spiraling descent into a tragic fate.
Opposite Clarke, Jack Huston’s portrayal of Mark Putnam is nuanced and chilling. Huston captures the complexity of a man who, despite his professional demeanor, is ultimately consumed by his own desires and moral failings. Together, the two actors form a potent on-screen partnership that anchors the film’s emotional core.
Thematic Depth: A Story of Power and Manipulation
At its heart, Above Suspicion is a story about power—both the overt power of law enforcement and the more subtle, insidious power of manipulation. The film dives deep into themes of gender, control, and addiction, showing how these elements intersect to create a devastating narrative of victimization and betrayal.
The film also explores the fragile nature of trust, especially in environments where survival is at stake. The tension between Susan and Putnam is palpable, with each character using the other to gain what they want, even as their manipulations take a tragic toll.
Visual and Narrative Style
The tone of Above Suspicion is dark and moody, which perfectly complements the tragic nature of its story. The visual style evokes a sense of isolation and claustrophobia, mirroring the inner turmoil of the characters. The cinematography captures the bleak, rugged landscape of the Appalachian region, adding an extra layer of tension to the film.
One of the most striking elements of the film is the use of Susan’s voiceover, which lends a fatalistic, noir-like quality to the narrative. Her reflections on the events that led to her downfall heighten the tragic inevitability of the story, reinforcing the sense that she was always doomed by her circumstances.
The Final Act: A Shocking Conclusion
The final act of Above Suspicion is both heart-wrenching and horrifying. The culmination of Susan and Mark’s toxic relationship leads to a shocking crime, the aftermath of which has far-reaching consequences. The film doesn’t shy away from the brutality of what happens next, leaving audiences with a lingering sense of unease and reflection.
Conclusion
Above Suspicion is a powerful, disturbing film that explores the complexities of human desire, desperation, and the consequences of manipulation. Emilia Clarke’s standout performance, combined with a taut, well-crafted narrative, makes it a must-see for fans of true-crime dramas. While it’s not an easy watch, the film is undeniably effective in capturing the dark, painful realities of its real-life inspiration. With its themes of betrayal, power, and the devastating impact of human flaws, Above Suspicion is a film that stays with you long after the credits roll.
